Ranking the Kings (and Queens) of Late-Night TV: Who Really Owns the Night?

Late-night TV has always been about choices. By the time homework is shoved aside and the clock strikes past 10:30, the real dilemma begins: who do you spend the next hour with—Fallon, Kimmel, Colbert? And just when you’ve settled in, another decision looms: who will keep you company for “late late” night?

With so many options (and endless skits, games, and viral segments), the world of late-night can feel overwhelming. To cut through the chaos, here’s a definitive ranking of America’s current late-night talk show hosts—judging not just their main stage presence, but also the extra content that makes their shows stand out. Netflix and premium cable hosts didn’t make the list—different rules, different playing field.

9. Last Call with Carson Daly

True to its name, Last Call really is the final option in late-night, airing at 1:35 a.m. Instead of goofy monologues and games, Daly opted for black-and-white interviews with quirky camera angles. A bold idea, but the execution often felt more like a sleep aid than entertainment. After 18 seasons, Daly called it quits, focusing instead on Today, The Voice, and even a Golf Channel project.

8. Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen

Andy Cohen carved out a different kind of late-night lane: celebrity gossip and reality-TV chaos. Airing earlier than most at 11 p.m., WWHL has lasted 16 seasons and clearly appeals to Bravo fans. But for those seeking sharp comedy or traditional talk show flair, it’s a miss.

7. The Daily Show with Trevor Noah

Taking over for Jon Stewart was a Herculean task, and while Trevor Noah brought global perspective and polish, the delivery sometimes fell flat. The writing team kept the show sharp, but Noah’s timing often left viewers missing Stewart’s punch.

6. Late Night with Seth Meyers

Seth Meyers shines in Weekend Update-style commentary, but stretching his comedy over an hour every night has been hit or miss. Six seasons in, Meyers feels safe but not groundbreaking. NBC clearly trusts him as a steady hand, but fans are still waiting for that breakout moment that proves he could one day inherit The Tonight Show.

5. The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon

Fallon’s boundless energy and constant laughter can be both his biggest strength and his greatest weakness. Guests love him, audiences laugh along, but sometimes the comedy feels forced. Thankfully, The Roots remain the crown jewel of his show—the best late-night band in the game, hands down.

4. Jimmy Kimmel Live!

After more than two decades, Kimmel’s staying power is undeniable. His blend of Hollywood connections, radio chops, and a knack for memorable bits keeps him at the top of the game. Yet the real MVP of the show may just be Guillermo Rodriguez—Kimmel’s sidekick, red-carpet correspondent, and a comedic force who often steals the spotlight.

3. The Late Late Show with James Corden

James Corden may be the rookie of the late-night scene, but he’s redefined the format with viral hits like Carpool Karaoke and Spill Your Guts or Fill Your Guts. His creativity and quick wit set him apart, and his segments live on across the internet long after the credits roll.

2. The Late Show with Stephen Colbert

Love him or loathe him, Colbert is one of the most authentic hosts on TV. His monologues are razor-sharp, his improv is unmatched, and his ability to stay true to himself resonates with fans. Even those who tire of his political focus admit he has one of the sharpest minds in late-night.

1. Conan

At the very top sits Conan O’Brien—a late-night legend with more than 25 years of experience. His unique brand of self-deprecating, absurdist humor has kept him relevant across generations. Even after trimming his show to a half-hour, Conan thrives by cutting the fat and focusing on what he does best: quick wit, improv mastery, and a willingness to poke fun at himself, his guests, and even his staff.

The Final Word

Late-night TV is more crowded than ever, but the hierarchy is clear. From Daly’s sleepy send-offs to Conan’s legendary improv, each host brings something different to the table. Still, only a few manage to balance tradition with innovation—and that’s what separates the good from the great when the lights go down.