NEWS: Female fencer takes a knee and walks out against transgender rival, as she tells ref: ‘I will not fence against a man’

In a move that has sparked both controversy and support across the sports world, a female fencer made headlines this weekend after refusing to compete against a transgender woman in a major fencing tournament. The incident occurred during the quarterfinal round of an international competition held in Europe, where 26-year-old American fencer Samantha Lewis took a knee on the piste and declared to the referee, “I will not fence against a man,” before walking off.

The dramatic gesture came just moments before the bout was scheduled to begin. Lewis, ranked among the top ten female foil fencers in the world, was set to face off against Elena Ivanov, a transgender athlete who has been competing in the women’s category for the past two years after undergoing hormone therapy and meeting international guidelines for gender eligibility.

Spectators were initially confused when Lewis remained still at the starting line, kneeling with her mask off. As the referee called for the match to begin, she raised her hand, stepped forward, and voiced her refusal. A hush fell over the venue, and within moments, Lewis left the piste and exited the hall. Tournament officials quickly gathered to address the situation, but the match was awarded to Ivanov by default due to Lewis’ forfeiture.

In a post-match interview, Lewis explained her actions. “This isn’t about hate or exclusion,” she said. “This is about fairness in sport. I respect everyone’s right to live as they choose, but when it comes to elite-level competition, we must draw lines to protect women’s categories.” She emphasized that she had no personal animosity toward Ivanov but felt compelled to make a stand on behalf of biological female athletes.

The fencing federation has not yet issued a formal statement on the incident, though sources inside the organization confirmed that an investigation is underway. Ivanov, who advanced to the semifinals, declined to comment directly on Lewis’ protest, but released a short statement later that evening expressing disappointment and reiterating her commitment to inclusion in sports.

Reactions to the incident have been deeply divided. Supporters of Lewis praised her for taking a principled stand and bringing attention to what they see as an imbalance in women’s sports caused by transgender inclusion. Critics, however, accused her of transphobia and called her actions disrespectful and contrary to the spirit of athletic competition.

Social media exploded with debate, with hashtags like #StandWithSamantha and #TransWomenAreWomen trending simultaneously. Prominent athletes, both past and present, weighed in, revealing the growing rift within women’s sports over how to handle transgender participation.

While fencing has rarely been the center of such heated cultural battles, this incident has thrust it into the spotlight, joining a broader international conversation about gender, identity, and fairness in sports. As governing bodies face increasing pressure to clarify policies, one thing is certain: the actions of Samantha Lewis have ignited a moment of reckoning that will not be easily ignored.